Breath of Clarity

Comment on Natural Resource Management Eras in the U.S.

Original Post by Professor Frank Turina:

It’s important that you mentioned Silent Spring. It really was one of the most influential books on society, technology, and the environment in the last 60 years. But why was it such a game-changer? Why are we still talking about it nearly sixty years after it was published?

After WWII, there was a sense that technology could save us from anything. Any problem could be solved through science. During that period, we had discovered antibiotics and developed vaccines. We had nearly wiped out polio and other diseases. Pesticides and herbicides and had increased crop yields, air travel was increasing, and the Apollo mission was getting us closer to the moon. It was a time of technological marvel. There was no limit to what we could achieve, and the chemical industry was a big part of that scene. Rachel Carson was one of the first to seriously question that narrative. She showed that there was a potential downside to technology. It really changed the way people viewed our relationship with science. Technical and scientific advances could help us solve problems, but there was a price to pay. It kind of burst our collective bubble and shined a bright light on the downsides of those advances. Carson’s book was so influential in areas far beyond environmentalism because it triggered a vast reexamination of our relationship with technology.

My Comment:

Hi Professor Turina,

I appreciate the depiction of Silent Spring’s legacy and have more to add about Rachel Caron’s approach. A large sum of the data and case studies that Carson drew from were not cutting-edge, new material to the scientific community. Carson was just a pioneer in consolidating, simplifying and broadcasting them for the general public. Her work involved jumpstarting a revolution to encourage people to be citizen-scientists. A key component of the environmental movement was the political support Carson generated which in turn brought her the establishment of a presidential committee to investigate pesticides. Further, in her testimony, Carson did not only identify problems. She presented the policy recommendations as well. She focused her proposals on citizen awareness about how pesticides were being used on their private property instead of solely focusing on a call for federal regulation. It was a phenomenal strategy to generate collective power.

Comment by Professor Frank Turina:

Her work was really influential to me. I loved her other books, Edge of the Sea and The Sea Around Us. I read them in high school and they inspired me to start college in Florida studying marine biology.